Most processors make their statements deliberately confusing. Here’s what every charge actually is, whether it’s legitimate, and what you can do about it.
The confusion is not accidental. Tiered pricing — the model most legacy processors use — is built on opacity. When you don’t understand your statement, you can’t push back. The charges below are annotated as Legitimate (real Visa/MC/issuer fees passed through), Avoidable (real fees but removable by switching processors or taking action), or Junk (invented by the processor with no underlying cost justification).
The standard line items
Qualified discount rate
The base rate applied to the cheapest transaction type: swiped debit cards and basic consumer Visa/Mastercard with no rewards. On tiered pricing, these are transactions that meet all of the processor’s “qualified” criteria. Usually 1.5–2.0% on tiered pricing. This is the rate advertised in most processor sign-up offers — the catch is that most of your transactions don’t qualify.
Legitimate
Mid-qualified surcharge
An extra charge applied to transactions that don’t meet the processor’s “qualified” criteria — typically rewards cards, hand-keyed transactions, or card-not-present charges. This is not a real Visa or Mastercard fee category. The processor invented it. Visa and Mastercard publish interchange rates by card type and transaction method; there is no Visa “mid-qualified” tier. It is a surcharge on top of a surcharge, using opaque criteria the processor sets internally. Typically adds 0.5–1.5% above the qualified rate.
Junk
Non-qualified surcharge
The highest tier in tiered pricing, applied to corporate cards, business cards, and ultra-premium rewards cards (Visa Infinite, Amex Platinum, etc.). Like the mid-qualified surcharge, this tiering is invented by the processor, not Visa or Mastercard. Can add 1.0–2.5% on top of the base qualified rate. If your business sees a lot of corporate card payments (B2B, high-ticket retail), non-qualified surcharges can make tiered pricing dramatically more expensive than the headline rate implies.
Junk
Monthly fee / service fee
A flat monthly charge just for having the account open, separate from any per-transaction costs. Common with Clover ($9.95+/month) and Heartland. Stripe and Square charge $0. At $9.95/month, you’re paying $119/year before processing a single transaction. For high-volume merchants, this may be offset by lower per-transaction rates; for low-volume businesses, it’s pure overhead.
Avoidable
PCI compliance fee
A monthly charge ($7–20/month) for being PCI compliant — meaning you’ve completed your annual Self-Assessment Questionnaire and passed a network vulnerability scan if required. The fee covers the processor’s cost of managing compliance reporting. Helcim includes PCI compliance at no charge. Most processors (Stripe, Square, Stax, Payment Depot) also charge $0. Clover charges $9.95/month.
Avoidable
PCI non-compliance fee
A monthly penalty ($20–50/month) charged when you
haven’t completed your annual PCI Self-Assessment Questionnaire. This one is entirely self-inflicted. The SAQ is free and takes 30–60 minutes at
pcisecuritystandards.org. Most small businesses in retail or restaurants qualify for SAQ-B or SAQ-C, the shortest versions. Complete it, submit your compliance confirmation to your processor, and the fee disappears — usually within one billing cycle.
Avoidable
Batch fee / settlement fee
A small fee ($0.05–0.25) charged each time you “batch” your transactions — the end-of-day process of submitting all transactions to your processor for settlement. If you process 25 days a month and pay $0.10 per batch, that’s $30/year. It’s a relic of older processing infrastructure. Stripe, Square, and Helcim don’t charge it. Clover charges $0.05 per batch. Not worth staying with a legacy processor for, but worth noting when comparing total costs.
Avoidable
Statement fee
A monthly charge ($5–15) for the processor generating and sending you your statement. You are being charged for the privilege of receiving a bill. Stripe, Square, and Helcim charge $0. If you’re paying a statement fee, your processor is pocketing pure margin — there is no network or interchange cost that justifies this charge.
Junk
Chargeback fee
A flat fee ($15–25) every time a customer disputes a charge with their bank, win or lose. All processors charge this — it reflects the actual administrative cost of the chargeback process, which involves multiple parties and dispute resolution workflows. Non-negotiable across the industry. The only way to reduce chargeback fees is to reduce chargebacks themselves: clear billing descriptors, prompt refunds, and delivery confirmation for e-commerce.
Legitimate
Early termination fee (ETF)
A penalty ($200–500) for canceling your contract before the term ends. Clover uses 36-month contracts with ETFs up to $500. Stripe, Square, Helcim, and Stax have no contracts and no ETF. If your current processor has an ETF, calculate whether the savings from switching justify paying it out early — on $30K/month in volume, switching from tiered to interchange-plus can save $1,500+/year, which pays off a $500 ETF in four months.
Avoidable
Red flag: If your statement shows mid-qualified or non-qualified surcharges, you are on tiered pricing — the most opaque pricing model in the industry. The processor invented these tiers; they do not correspond to any real Visa or Mastercard fee category. Interchange-plus pricing shows you the exact same underlying costs in plain English, with a fixed markup on top. Compare the two models.
How to calculate what you’re actually paying
Your statement’s headline rates are not your effective rate. To find what you actually paid per dollar processed:
- Add up all fees on your statement — processing fees, monthly fees, PCI fees, statement fees, batch fees, everything.
- Divide by your total processing volume for the same month.
- Multiply by 100 to get a percentage.
Example: $960 in total fees on $30,000 in volume = 3.20% effective rate. Benchmark: in-person retail should be 2.0–2.5%. If you’re at 3.2%, you have room to save $210–$360/month by switching to interchange-plus pricing.
Compare processors that don’t use tiered pricing — enter your volume to see real monthly costs.
Compare processors →